Technik

waiting for a bite 1874 winslow homer
By Winslow Homer 1874

In diesen Artikeln geht es um die technische Umsetzung von Aquaponik-, Hydroponik und wie diese Systeme zu gestalten, zu warten und zu betreiben sind. Ob es um das Messen von Ec, pH,  wichtigen Nährstoffaspekten oder die Handhabung der Messtechnik geht, haben wir hier einige hoffentlich hilfreiche Artikel verfasst und zusammengestellt.

Wir hoffen hier Ihr Interesse an der Thematik zu wecken, die Hemmschwelle zu senken und es einfach selbst zu probieren. Was hat das mit dem Bild Waiting for a bite, 1874 von Winslow Homer zu tun ? Ohne das nötige wissen nützt Ihnen auch die beste Ausrüstung nichts.

KAT ID: 8
Whether decoupled Aquaponics (DAPS: Decoupled Aquaponics System) has a general advantage over conventional recirculating aquaponics systems is much debated on the internet and in academia. Finding this out has been our goal over the last few years and led to the publication "Navigating Decoupled Aquaponics Systems: A system dynamics design approach ". Following the KISS principle (Keep it simple, stupid!), I will briefly outline the main points of the publication and discuss them a bit in non-scientific jargon (without the abstract of the paper).
 
 
DAPS Decoupled Aquaponics System ( Entkoppeltes Aquaponiksystem )
HP Hydroponik
RAS Rezirkulierendes Aquakultur System

 

 

 

Abstract

The classic working principle of aquaponics is to supply a hydroponic plant culture unit with nutrient-rich aquaculture water, which in turn purifies the water that is returned to the aquaculture tanks. A known drawback is that a compromise away from optimal growing conditions for plants and fish must be achieved to produce both crops and fish under the same environmental conditions. The aim of this study was to develop a theoretical concept of a decoupled aquaponics system (DAPS) and predict water, nutrient (N and P), fish, sludge and plant values.

flow ras daps smallThis was addressed by developing a dynamic aquaponic system model using inputs from data in the literature covering aquaculture, hydroponics and sludge treatment. The results of the model showed the dependence of aquaculture water quality on hydroponic evapotranspiration rate. This result can be explained by the fact that DAPS is based on one-way flows. These one-way flows lead to accumulations of remineralised nutrients in the hydroponic component, which ensure optimal conditions for the plants. The study also suggests sizing the cropping area based on P availability in the hydroponic component, as P is a depletable resource and has been identified as one of the most important limiting factors for plant growth.

 

Decoupled aquaponics

Although many aquaponics systems are designed and operated as recirculating systems, commercial growers and researchers are expanding this initial aquaponics system design to include independent control over each system unit (i.e. RAS, hydroponics and nutrient recovery through sludge remineralisation: recirculated aquaculture systems).
Decoupled aquaponics systems (DAPS) are systems in which fish, plants and, where appropriate, remineralisation are integrated as separate functional units consisting of individual water circuits that can be controlled independently. The difference between the concepts of one-loop and multi-loop (i.e. decoupled) aquaponics systems can be seen in Figures 1 and 2. In the context of recycling all nutrients entering the system, decoupled aquaponics can be seen as a preferred option as they avoid additional discharge.

 small recirc

Abb. 1 - The one-loop aquaponics system is the traditional aquaponics approach. Instead of supplementing the hydroponic part with fertiliser, both components are exposed to quite similar conditions

 

small decoupled

Abb. 2 - In contrast to a single-loop aquaponics system, a multi-loop aquaponics system aims to create optimal conditions for both fish and plants. In this case, the fish sludge coming from the RAS is remineralised and fed to the hydroponics.

 

Figure 3 shows a process flow drawing of a basic DAPS layout. Please note - this is only an example and can be adapted in a modular way. The blue tags in the figure include the RAS component, the green tags include the hydroponic component and the red tags include the remineralisation components. The sequence of the components is represented numerically in the tags and refers to the vertical direction in which the flow must move.
This means that high numbers refer to high positioning and low numbers to low positioning.
 

entkoppelte aquaponik

Während RAS (Rezirkulierten AquakulturSysteme) und Hydroponik seit Jahrzehnten Gegenstand der Forschung sind, steckt die Remineralisierung von Fischschlamm noch in den Kinderschuhen. In der Abhandlung haben wir die Vor- und Nachteile der aeroben Vor- und Nachbehandlung der anaeroben Vergärung diskutiert, derzeit untersuchen wir jedoch die Leistung der reinen anaeroben Vergärung. Wir werden Sie auf dieser Website über unsere Ergebnisse auf dem Laufenden halten.

Leider müssen wir alle enttäuschen, die sich dafür begeistert haben, ein entkoppeltes Aquaponik-System in ihrem Garten zu bauen. Entkoppelte Aquaponiksysteme erfordern viel Steuerungstechnik und sind nur sinnvoll, wenn man bereit ist, hohe Nährlösungen in der Hydrokultureinheit zu erzielen. Außerdem ist die Dimensionierung des Systems im Vergleich zur Dimensionierung herkömmlicher Systeme mit einer Schleife viel komplexer. Die Ermittlung der erforderlichen Evapotranspirationsrate der hydroponischen Pflanzen, die erforderlich ist, um eine Akkumulation von Stickstoffformen im RAS zu vermeiden, erhöht die Komplexität zusätzlich. Folglich sind diese Art von Systemen am besten für kommerzielle Systeme im großen Maßstab geeignet, insbesondere wegen ihrer Fähigkeit, mit kommerziellen Hydrokultursystemen zu konkurrieren.

 

Growth benefits

The sweet spot of aquaponics for most people is the sustainable approach as well as the symbiotic effect of the RAS water on the plants and vice versa. From a commercial point of view, you cannot convince farmers with these arguments, even though they might be valid. In recent experiments, we observed growth benefits from decoupled aquaponics systems. We observed a 39 % increase in plant growth compared to a pure hydroponic control nutrient solution when supplementing the hydroponic component with additional fertiliser. Furthermore, we were able to show that anaerobic digestate also increased plant growth. At the moment, it seems that both the RAS water and the digestate contain plant growth-promoting rhizobacteria (PGPR), which could promote plant growth. We are currently planning further experiments on this topic and will also try to identify and isolate some of these PGPR.
 

Sensitive fish species

In the article we explained why decoupled aquaponics is suitable for sensitive fish species. We found that the use of artificial greenhouse light leads to lower fluctuations in RAS nutrient concentrations because plant evapotranspiration is more constant. The extent to which artificial lighting pays off needs to be investigated in a harvest- and fish-dependent economic evaluation.

 

 

Hybrid backyard approach

The hybrid decoupled system is a combination of the one-loop and decoupled approaches (Fig. 4). Home and garden growers who still want to get into decoupled aquaponics may want to try this approach. Resizing an existing system would be obsolete, as the remineralised sludge would serve as a source of nutrients for the additional culture beds. 

hybrid system

Abb. 4 - Hybrides entkoppeltes Aquaponic-System. Ein Ansatz für Heimgärtner?

 

Conclusion

We believe that decoupled aquaponics systems have the potential to achieve similar or even higher performance than hydroponic production. We know this is a bold statement, but recent observations support these assumptions. However, whether these growth advantages of DAPS over hydroponics can still be observed under perfect growing conditions (i.e. optimal climate control, light intensity and CO2 addition) remains to be clarified. The decisive advantage, however, is the sustainable approach, which aims to recycle everything that enters the system. This aspect alone is a full justification for decoupled aquaponics.
Regarding the remineralisation component, there is a need for further research on its remineralisation performance depending on different hydraulic retention times (HRT) and sludge retention times (SRT). In summary, while technical research in this area is important, additional geographically dependent follow-up studies are needed that address the economically feasible size of DAPS as well as comparison with equivalent hydroponic systems.

 

Sources:
 
This article is based on excerpts, additions, summaries and translations of various scientific publications. Among others, the following were used:
 

MDPI and ACS Style
Goddek, S.; Espinal, C.A.; Delaide, B.; Jijakli, M.H.; Schmautz, Z.; Wuertz, S.; Keesman, K.J. Navigating towards Decoupled Aquaponic Systems: A System Dynamics Design Approach. Water 2016, 8, 303. https://doi.org/10.3390/w8070303

AMA Style
Goddek S, Espinal CA, Delaide B, Jijakli MH, Schmautz Z, Wuertz S, Keesman KJ. Navigating towards Decoupled Aquaponic Systems: A System Dynamics Design Approach. Water. 2016; 8(7):303. https://doi.org/10.3390/w8070303

Chicago/Turabian Style
Goddek, Simon, Carlos Alberto Espinal, Boris Delaide, Mohamed Haissam Jijakli, Zala Schmautz, Sven Wuertz, and Karel J. Keesman. 2016. "Navigating towards Decoupled Aquaponic Systems: A System Dynamics Design Approach" Water 8, no. 7: 303. https://doi.org/10.3390/w8070303

Decoupled Aquaponics – The Future of Food Growing?

http://www.developonics.com/2016/07/decoupled-aquaponics/

Navigating towards Decoupled Aquaponic Systems: A System Dynamics Design Approach
https://www.mdpi.com/2073-4441/8/7/303/htm

Kontext: 
 ID: 398

IP Schutzklasse Nomenklatur

Alle unsere Steueranlagen werden einer IP-Schutzklasse zugeordnet um die Umgebungsbedingungen für den Betrieb klar zu definieren. Hier eine Übersicht der von uns verwendeten Klassifizierungen.

 

Den in der Schutzartbezeichnung immer vorhandenen Buchstaben IP werden zwei Kennziffern (im Allgemeinen ohne Zwischenraum) angehängt. Diese zeigen an, welchen Schutzumfang ein Gehäuse bezüglich Berührung bzw. Fremdkörper (erste Kennziffer) und Feuchtigkeit bzw. Wasser (zweite Kennziffer) bietet.

Wenn eine der beiden Kennziffern nicht angegeben werden muss oder soll, wird diese durch den Buchstaben X ersetzt (zum Beispiel „IPX1“). Bei Bedarf können an die Ziffernkombination noch definierte Buchstaben zur genaueren Beschreibung der Schutzart angehängt werden. So sieht ISO 20653 den Buchstaben K für die Kennzeichnung der Ausrüstung von Straßenfahrzeugen bei einzelnen Kennziffern vor.

Erste Kennziffer des IP-Codes - Schutz gegen Fremdkörper und Berührung

1. KennzifferBedeutung:
ISO 20653DIN EN 60529Schutz gegen FremdkörperSchutz gegen Berührung
0 kein Schutz kein Schutz
1 Geschützt gegen feste Fremdkörper mit Durchmesser ≥ 50 mm Geschützt gegen den Zugang mit dem Handrücken
2 Geschützt gegen feste Fremdkörper mit Durchmesser ≥ 12,5 mm Geschützt gegen den Zugang mit einem Finger
3 Geschützt gegen feste Fremdkörper mit Durchmesser ≥ 2,5 mm Geschützt gegen den Zugang mit einem Werkzeug
4 Geschützt gegen feste Fremdkörper mit Durchmesser ≥ 1,0 mm Geschützt gegen den Zugang mit einem Draht
5K 5 Geschützt gegen Staub in schädigender Menge vollständiger Schutz gegen Berührung
6K 6 staubdicht vollständiger Schutz gegen Berührung

Genauere Erläuterungen finden sich in den jeweiligen Normen.

Hinweis: Während DIN EN 60529 IP5X und IP6X definiert, heißen diese beiden Schutzarten in ISO 20653 Teil 9 IP5KX und IP6KX.

 

Zweite Kennziffer des IP-Codes - Schutz gegen Wasser

2. KennzifferBedeutung:
Schutz gegen Wasser
ISO 20653DIN EN 60529
0 kein Schutz
1 Schutz gegen Tropfwasser
2 Schutz gegen fallendes Tropfwasser, wenn das Gehäuse bis zu 15° geneigt ist
3 Schutz gegen fallendes Sprühwasser bis 60° gegen die Senkrechte
4 Schutz gegen allseitiges Spritzwasser
4K   Schutz gegen allseitiges Spritzwasser mit erhöhtem Druck
5 Schutz gegen Strahlwasser (Düse) aus beliebigem Winkel
6 Schutz gegen starkes Strahlwasser
6K   Schutz gegen starkes Strahlwasser unter erhöhtem Druck, spezifisch für Straßenfahrzeuge
7 Schutz gegen zeitweiliges Untertauchen
8 Schutz gegen dauerndes Untertauchen. Soweit keine andere Angabe erfolgt, besteht ein Schutz bis 1 Meter Wassertiefe. Andere Wassertiefen müssen separat angegeben bzw. vereinbart werden
  9 Schutz gegen Wasser bei Hochdruck-/Dampfstrahlreinigung, speziell Landwirtschaft
9K   Schutz gegen Wasser bei Hochdruck-/Dampfstrahlreinigung, spezifisch für Straßenfahrzeuge

Genauere Erläuterungen finden sich in den jeweiligen Normen.

Hinweis: DIN EN 60529 definiert nicht IPX9K. ISO 20653 definiert kein IPX9, sondern nur IPX9K.

Bis zum Schutzgrad IPX6 (bei DIN EN 60529) bzw. IPX6K (bei ISO 20653) sind die darunter liegenden Schutzgrade eingeschlossen. Bei den höheren Schutzarten gilt dies für die Wasserschutzgrade 7, 8 und 9K nicht automatisch. Falls ein Einschluss einer niedrigeren Schutzart gefordert wird, ist dies durch eine Doppelbezeichnung angegeben, beispielsweise IPX6K/IPX9K.

Quelle: https://de.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schutzart

Harvey W. Wiley conducting experiments in his laboratory
Harvey W. Wiley conducting
experiments in his laboratory

Electric conductivity

Electrical conductivity , also known as conductivity or EC value (from English electrical conductivity ), is a physical quantity that indicates how strong the ability of a substance is to conduct electric current. This value, among many others, is used to control the fertilizer concentration in aquaponics and hydroponics. 

 
 

Water / Nutrients – Conductivity EC

Water is an important building material for plant growth and provides the plant with moisture, necessary for metabolic processes. It is also a carrier of nutrients and contains dissolved oxygen. Important properties of water are hardness, salt content, pH and alkalinity. The proportion of dissolved minerals is checked by measuring the electrical conductivity (EC - electrical conductivity), given in µS/cm, sometimes also in mS/cm (1000 µS/cm = 1 mS/cm). 

The right nutrient selection and the right amount are important. In order to avoid under- or over-fertilization, the nutrient content is checked by measuring the electrical conductivity (EC). The higher the salt content, the higher the conductivity. The following definition is “arbitrary” but widely used.

Soft water – approx. 0 – 140 µS/cm
Hard water - > 840 µS/cm

As we can see, water already contains a certain  amount of dissolved nutrients , depending on its hardness . The missing nutrients are  added via hydroponic fertilizer . Fewer nutrients are needed at the beginning of growth and in the final stages.

A conductivity between approx. 1000 – 2000 µS/cm covers pretty much all needs. As an average guideline  value, we consider 1500 µS/cm  to be a working value (experience values). But it is always important to observe the plants.

Manufacturers of hydroponic fertilizers provide information on dosage and conductivity values, depending on the growth stage.

 

 

The higher the temperature, the lower the oxygen content in the nutrient solution:

Temperature (°C) Dissolved oxygen in water (mg/l)
10 11.30
15 10.00
20 9.00
25 8.30
30 7.60
35 7:00
40 6.40
45 6:00 am

 

 

pH value hydroponics - approx. pH 6.2

The acidity (pH value) of the water influences the availability of nutrients for the plants. A wide range of nutrients can best be absorbed by the roots in a  pH range of 5.5 - 6.5  , regardless of the cultivation method.

The pH should be measured and adjusted to create favorable growth conditions. Since the plants do not like a pH change that is too rapid, the pH value adjustment should be done gradually.

The following rounded minimums and maximums from the 4 nutrient formulas are good guidelines for your own hydroponic nutrient solution:

element mg/l = ppm
Nitrogen (N) 170 – 235
Phosphorus (P) 30 – 60
Potassium (K) 150 – 300
Calcium (Ca) 160 – 185
Magnesium (Mg) 35 – 50
Sulfur (S) 50-335
Iron (Fe) 2.5 – 12
Manganese (Mn) 0.5 – 2.0
Copper (Cu) 0.02 – 0.1
Zinc (Zn) 0.05 – 0.1
Molybdenum (Mo) 0.01 – 0.2
boron (B) 0.3 – 0.5

 

 

When growing hydroponically, it is advisable to allow the pH to fluctuate slightly within 6-7 pH. As you can see in the figure, some nutrients can only be absorbed at the lower or upper range of the optimal range. 

     
ph value soil    pH value hydroponics 1

 

 

Herbs for growing in hydroponics

Herbs thrive in hydroponics, grow very well and you can grow many herbs in a small space. If, as with classic cultivation in soil, you take into account the requirements for sun, partial shade or shade and keep an eye on the water-nutrient mixture, you can look forward to a rich harvest.

Regular pruning also promotes plant growth. The list shows herbs that are well suited for hydroponic cultivation, but does not claim to be complete.    

 

Herbs
  • valerian
  • basil
  • Savory
  • Borage
  • Watercress
  • Calendula
  • dill
  • Echinacea
  • Angelica
  • tarragon
  • fennel
  • Goldenseal
  • chamomile
  • Catnip
  • chervil
  • coriander 
  • cumin
  • lavender
  • Lovage
  • dandelion
  • marjoram
  • Mint, all varieties
  • Feverfew
  • oregano
  • Parsley
  • Pimpinelle
  • peppermint
  • Rue / rocket
  • rosemary
  • sage
  • chives
  • Cut celery
  • Stevia
  • thyme
  • Thai basil
  • Wormwood
  • Hyssop (verbena)
  • Lemon basil
  • Lemongrass
  • Lemon balm

 

Vegetables for growing in hydroponics

Actually, you can grow almost all plants hydroponically, except root vegetables. Fast-growing varieties such as pak choi, Asian lettuce or chard are interesting because they can be harvested frequently. But many other types of vegetables also deliver high yields quickly and taste very good at the same time. The list shows examples of which vegetables can be cultivated hydroponically. 

  • eggplant
  • Asian salad
  • cauliflower
  • Beans
  • Broccoli
  • chili
  • endive salad
  • Peas
  • Strawberries
  • Green mustard
  • Kale
  • Cucumbers
  • Kohlrabi
  • herb
  • pumpkin
  • Leek
  • Chard
  • Melons
  • Mizuna - Japanese salad
  • okra
  • Pak choi
  • paprika
  • Brussels sprouts
  • Red mustard

 

 

pH value and EC value for crops

 

 

 

pH values ​​and EC values ​​for ornamental plants

 

 

 

 EC values ​​for hemp plants

hemp ec valuesph ec hemp

 

Composition of a hydroponic nutrient solution (standard nutrient solution)

In hydroponic science, extensive research has been and is being carried out to find the best nutrient solution. Four standard nutrient formulas from Hoagland & Arnon (1938), Hewitt (1966), Cooper (1979) and Steiner (1984) are particularly well known. These are general standard nutrient solutions.

Here you will find a short introduction to how you can create nutrient solutions yourself.

The following rounded minimums and maximums from the 4 nutrient formulas are good guidelines for your own hydroponic nutrient solution:

 

Element mg/l = ppm
Nitrogen (N) 170 – 235
Phosphorus (P) 30 – 60
Potassium (K) 150 – 300
Calcium (Ca) 160 – 185
Magnesium (Mg) 35 – 50
Sulfur (S) 50-335
Iron (Fe) 2.5 – 12
Manganese (Mn) 0.5 – 2.0
Copper (Cu) 0.02 – 0.1
Zinc (Zn) 0.05 – 0.1
Molybdenum (Mo) 0.01 – 0.2
Boron (B) 0.3 – 0.5

 

 

pH of the nutrient solution and nutrient availability

In order for your plant to grow and thrive in hydroponics, your nutrient solution must have a certain pH value. If the pH value is too high or too low, important nutrients are not available to the plant.

In most cases, the ideal pH value of the nutrient solution is between 5.5 – 6.5 . Most nutrients are available in this area. If you want to perfect yield and growth, you should find out about specific pH values ​​for plants in hydroponics. Here is a diagram about the pH value and the availability of nutrients:

Nutrient availability pH value hydroponics

 Graphic: Pennsylvania State University

 

Context: 

ID: 162

This shortened overview serves as an aid in estimating the magnitude of the analytical technology required when analyzing and controlling the nutrients with which the plants are fertilized.

The quality of analysis in chemistry has already reached a level of precision that is unnecessary for our purposes of controlled fertilization. In order not to shoot at sparrows when selecting the various analysis methods and analysis devices, we have listed here a very shortened overview of the necessary accuracies that are sufficient for checking the individual additives. The technology used in the chosen analysis method has a major influence on the overall operating costs.

In addition to checking the necessary substances, monitoring is also necessary to prevent over-fertilization. The nutrients produced by fish farming must not exceed a certain concentration, otherwise this will impair the optimal growth of the plants.

There are now a very large number of analysis methods on the market, which differ greatly in both the technology used and the on-site application. This overview will help you, even without our advice , to obtain offers from different manufacturers that exactly meet your needs. Here is a random selection of manufacturers.


Here you will find the essential compounds required for plant growth. Depending on the plant and/or growth phase, the form of administration, the chemical compound in which the desired “substance” is bound, can or must vary. In the previous cultivation method (in the soil), the microorganisms and fungi caused the necessary compounds to be broken down. Since no microorganisms take on this task in hydroponics, this is still a current area of ​​basic research.

Compounds and trace elements / orders of magnitude in nutrient solutions

K

potassium

0.5 - 10 mmol/L

Approx

calcium

0.2 - 5 mmol/L

S

sulfur

0.2 - 5 mmol/L

P

phosphorus

0.1 - 2 mmol/L

Mg

magnesium

0.1 - 2 mmol/L

Fe

iron

2 - 50 µmol/L

Cu

copper

0.5 - 10 µmol/L

Zn

zinc

0.1 - 10 µmol/L

Mn

manganese

0 - 10 µmol/L

b

boron

0 - 0.01 ppm

Mo

molybdenum

0 - 100 ppm

NO2

nitrite

0 – 100 mg/L

NO3

nitrate

0 – 100 mg/L

NH4

ammonia

0.1 - 8 mg/L

KNO3

Potassium nitrate

0 - 10 mmol/L

Ca(NO3)2

Calcium nitrate

0 - 10 mmol/L

NH4H2PO4

Ammonium dihydrogen phosphate

0 - 10 mmol/L

(NH4)2HPO4

Diammonium hydrogen phosphate

0 - 10 mmol/L

MgSO4

Magnesium sulfate

0 - 10 mmol/L

Fe-EDTA

Ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid

0 – 0.1 mmol/L

H3BO3

Boric acid

0 – 0.01 mmol/L

KCl

Potassium chloride

0 – 0.01 mmol/L

MnSO4

Manganese (II) sulfate

0 – 0.001 mmol/L

ZnSO4

Zinc sulfate

0 – 0.001 mmol/L

FeSO4

Iron(II) sulfate

0 – 0.0001 mmol/L

CuSO4

Copper sulfate

0 - 0.0002 mmol/L

MoO3

Molybdenum oxide

0 – 0.0002 mmol/L

When it comes to nutrient solutions, you will always find concentration information that is given either in mg/l, ppm or moles. Here is a little help on how these values ​​are converted into one another. You will often find measuring ranges given with a second citation form, for example nitrate as nitrate (NO 3 ) and as nitrate-nitrogen (NO 3 -N).
 

Conversion: Mol and PPM

A technical definition of ppm

What is ppm? And how can something called "parts per million" be represented by mg/L? Parts per million indicates the number of "parts" of something in a million "parts" of something else. The "part" can be any unit, but when mixing solutions, ppm usually represents units of weight. In this context, ppm indicates how many grams of a solute there are per million grams of solvent (e.g. water).

1 g dissolved / 1,000,000 g solvent

When dealing with water at room temperature, it is common to assume that the density of the water is equal to 1 g/ml. Therefore we can describe the relationship as follows:

1 g dissolved in 1,000,000 ml of water

Then we divide ml by 1000 ml:

1 g dissolved in 1,000 L water

By dividing both units by 1000, the ratio becomes:

1 mg dissolved in 1 L water

Therefore, one can say 1 mg in 1 L of water is the same as 1 mg in 1,000,000 mg of water, or 1 part per million (assuming both room temperature and an atmospheric pressure of 1 atmosphere).

 

How do you convert ppm to moles?

To convert ppm to molarity or molarity to ppm, you only need to know the molar mass of the dissolved element or molecule. Here is a periodic table for the molar masses (top left: the atomic weight).

Take the molarity mol/L and multiply by its molar mass
g/mol to get g/L. Multiply by 1000 again to convert grams to milligrams and you have mg/L for aqueous solutions.

 

Example: Prepare a NaOH solution

You have a stock solution of 1 molar NaOH. How do you go about creating a 1L solution of 200 ppm NaOH? NaOH has a molar mass of 39,997 g/mol.

1. Convert 200 ppm to molarity.

First let's assume 200 ppm = 200 mg/L. Then divide the result by 1000 and you get g/L:  200 mg/L divided by 1000 mg/g equals 0.2 g/L.

Next, divide 0.2 g/L by the molar mass of NaOH (Na=22.9 O=16 H=1) to get the molarity: 0.2 g/L divided by 39,997 g/mol which is 0.005 mole /L.

2. Calculate the dilution recipe.

From step 1 we know the target molarity of 0.005 mol/L. To calculate the dilution we use the dilution equation:  m1⋅v1=m2⋅v2

where:
• m1— the concentration of the stock solution;
• m2— the concentration of the diluted solution;
• v1—the volume of the stock solution; and
• v2 - The volume of the diluted solution

We can enter the numbers for all variables except the volume of the stock solution:

1 M ⋅ v1 = 0.005 M ⋅ 1 L


By rearranging the equation, we find the required volume of the stock solution:
v1 = 0.005 M / 1 M  ⋅ 1 L = 0.005 L

Therefore we need to dilute 0.005 L (or 5 ml) stock solution to a final volume of
1 L and so we get 200 ppm NaOH solution.

 

How do I calculate ppm from volume concentration?

How to get volume ppm:

Take the molar concentration of the solutions in mol/L.
Multiply it by the molar mass in g/mol.
Divide it by the density of the solute in g/cm³.
Multiply everything by 1000 mg/g.
The resulting ppm volume unit is typically μL/L.


You can find a slightly more detailed example here for both conversion directions:

Convert moles to grams

Convert grams to moles

HowTos and measuring devices

 

Additional information:

https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wasseranalyse  ( local copy )

http://www.anwickele-geologie.geol.uni-erlangen.de/paramete.htm

SI prefixes
Surname Yotta Zetta Exa Peta Tera Giga Mega kilo Hecto Deca
symbol Y Z E P T G M k H there
factor 10 24 10 21 10 18 10 15 10 12 10 9 10 6 10 3 10 2 10 1
Surname Yokto Zepto Atto Femto Piko Nano Micro Milli Centi Dec
symbol y e.g a f p n µ m c d
factor 10 −24 10 −21 10 −18 10 −15 10 −12 10 −9 10 −6 10 −3 10 −2 10 −1
 ID: 

TDS, EC, and PPM explained in brief

Fast growth and high yields are the main goals in aqua and hydroponics. This success is decided by many details.
As a grower, you need to find the comfort zone of nutrient strength so that your plants can grow properly. If you add too many nutrients, the plants will be affected by a severe case of nutrient burn. Too few nutrients will cause the plant to wither or produce only a low yield.
Do not wait for the symptoms to appear. Prevention is better in hydroponics than damage or even total loss.
 
Important here: check the nutrient solution regularly. To get a complete picture, you need to analyse certain physical and chemical properties of your nutrient solution.
 
Here you will come across terms like TDS, EC and PPM. These terms revolve around the concentration of dissolved nutrients - more precisely, the parts of the nutrient solution that are dissolved in the water, through which the salinity can be determined. For more details on electrical conductance, see Wikipedia.
Another hurdle is that malformations or deficiencies can easily be misinterpreted. Here is a brief overview of the nutrients that can get in each other's way if they are wrongly concentrated and in the worst case can even completely block nutrient uptake.
 
Before we get down to business, here's what these abbreviations stand for:
 
TDS: Totally Dissolved Solids.
EC: Electrical Conductivity
PPM: Parts per Million (Parts per MIllion)

 

What are completely dissolved solids (TDS)?

Water is described as a universal solvent capable of dissolving a wide range of organic and inorganic compounds and minerals. The TDS value of water measures the total amount of minerals dissolved in the water. The solids are dissolved either in the form of ions, molecules or tiny micro-granular particles that cannot be filtered out with normal filters (size of two micrometres).
 
This measurement is usually used in the context of fresh water. For salt water, the term "salinity" is used, which basically says the same thing. The TDS value is a measure of water quality, but not a direct indication of pollution. It provides information about the amount of dissolved solids, not about the dissolved substances themselves. All water, including drinking water, contains various minerals and compounds in solution. Tap water contains calcium, magnesium and of course chlorine ions. Bottled mineral water contains even more dissolved minerals than tap water.
 
The higher the TDS value of a water sample, the lower its suitability for various purposes. The dissolved solids in water are measured in ppm. As a guide, here are some TDS values that occur in nature:
 
Freshwater - TDS less than 1000ppm (WHO standards).
Brackish water - TDS up to 5000ppm
Saltwater - TDS between 15,000 - 30,000
Seawater - TDS between 30,000 and 40,000ppm
Brine - TDS above 40,000ppm
In the context of hydroponics, the TDS value gives you a clear idea of the strength or concentration of your nutrient solution. This will give you accurate information about the amount of nutrients your plants are receiving from the water.

 

 

What is electrical conductivity (EC)?

Water is a good conductor of electricity, which is why many electrocution accidents occur in bathrooms. But did you know that pure water is an excellent insulator! Pure water, i.e. H2O without any other minerals or molecules dissolved in it, does not conduct electricity. However, as soon as mineral salts are dissolved in it, the electrical properties of water change drastically.
 
And since water is very corrosive, it easily dissolves many minerals, salts and compounds. For this reason, all waters found in our environment prove to be good conductors of electric current.
Salts form charged particles called ions in water. These include positively charged cations (which consist of metals) and negatively charged anions (which consist of non-metals).
Even a small amount of dissolved salts is enough to drastically increase the electrical conductivity of the water. And the more salts dissolved in the water, the higher the number of ions and the higher the electrical conductivity of the water.
 
How does this affect hydroponics? Well, the vast majority of nutrients used in hydroponics contain salts such as nitrates and phosphates. So when you add nutrients, the EC value of the water increases. If you measure the EC value, you can get a pretty good idea of the nutrient concentration in your water.
 
The EC value is measured with two interconnected units. These are MilliSiemens and MicroSiemens. For orientation: 1 MilliSiemens = 1000 MicroSiemens.
 
A quick look at parts per million (PPM).
We have already mentioned ppm when explaining TDS. In chemistry, ppm is a common value used to describe substances dissolved in minute amounts in air, water and soil. PPM is basically analogous to a percentage. Just as a percent means one in a hundred, a ppm is equivalent to one part in a million of something.
 
You will often see ppm used to measure the level of pollution in water and air. PPM is easier to understand if you use the metric system. For example, to achieve a salt concentration of 1ppm in water, you need to dissolve 1 milligram of salt in 1 litre of water. (or 1 gram in 10,000 litres!)

 

 

What is the relationship between TDS and EC?
 
As you know by now, the TDS value gives you an accurate idea of the amount of dissolved solids in a water sample. And the EC value gives you a clear picture of the salt concentration in a water sample.
In the environment, there is often only a partial correlation between electrical conductivity and TDS value. In a hydroponic growing system, however, the relationship is more direct for several reasons.
Take, for example, the water in a lake or well. It contains a significant amount of dissolved minerals, salts and other organic and inorganic compounds. Only a fraction of the total TDS, namely the salts, affect the EC.
However, hydroponic growers try to use higher quality water for their plants whenever possible. And almost all components of hydroponic nutrient mixtures are in the form of easily soluble salts.
Therefore, EC and TDS values in hydroponic nutrient solutions are more directly related due to the high proportion of dissolved salts. Your main goal as a grower is to get an accurate estimate of the concentration of your nutrient solution. Both TDS and EC values are a viable way to obtain this information.
 
If you know one value, you can calculate the other with the help of a so-called conversion factor.
Not all salts have the same electrical conductivity. If one salt increases the EC value of the water by one microsiemens at a TDS value of 1500 ppm, another salt may only need 1000 ppm to achieve the same result.
So depending on the salt, you will need a suitable conversion factor to get an accurate TDS value. This factor is normally between 0.5 and 0.8, so the basic formula for calculating TDS or EC is
 
TDS = ke*EC (where KE is the conversion factor).
 
Another important factor that can affect the above equation is the temperature of the water. The EC value of a salt solution can fluctuate with temperature changes. The higher the temperature, the better the electrical conductivity.
 

How to measure TDS and EC
 
There are several ways to measure both TDS and EC. For example, one method commonly used in laboratories is to evaporate the liquid and then measure the residue.
However, from the perspective of the average hydroponic grower/hobbyist, advanced laboratory measurements are not applicable. Instead, most growers use simple handheld meters to measure either TDS or EC. You can use either an EC meter or a TDS meter.
 
A TDS meter is actually nothing more than an EC meter that has a built-in conversion system. This
system is programmed to use a specific Ke factor to get the result in ppm or mg/L instead of milliSiemens.
But here is a fundamental problem: some TDS meters use a conversion factor of 442, which gives the EC value for a mixture of 4 parts sodium sulphate, 4 parts sodium bicarbonate and 2 parts sodium chloride. The formula for the conversion is 700 x EC in milliSiemens.
 
Others use a simple sodium chloride conversion factor, which is considered by some to be closer to the EC of a hydroponic mixture. The formula here is 500 x EC in millisiemens.
 
So depending on the conversion factor used, you get different results with a variation of about 600ppm. That is a wide range for hydroponics. So how do you know if you have the right measurement?
The easiest way is to stick to the EC measurement. However, if you must use TDS, check the source of information. If a book or nutrient mixing guide gives the PPM value, it will usually also give the conversion factor used.
Use this information to calculate the exact final value. In the USA, 500 or 650 ke is commonly used, while 700 ke is preferred in the UK and Europe.
 
 
Control of EC/TDS in nutrient solutions
 
Measuring, calculating and determining the correct EC or TDS value is the difficult part. Dealing with these values, on the other hand, is deceptively easy!
The most important thing is to follow the recommended nutrient values, either in MilliSiemens or PPM. If you are using a commercial nutrient mix, this will be clearly stated on the label.
If the EC level is too low, add more nutrients, and if it is higher than the recommended levels, add more water. That's it. 
 
Remember that these are concentrated mixtures and that a small amount is often enough. But with practice you will soon get the hang of it. Different hydroponics have different PPM values.

 

Here you will find the Ec and PPM table of some popular vegetables. TO_DO


However, the PPM value mentioned above only gives information about the general condition of your nutrient solution. It says nothing about the specific mineral content in the nutrient solution. Again, each plant requires different specific mineral ppm. Let's take a look at the recommended concentrations of the main elements in crop nutrient solutions.

 

Data of the main elements in mg/L (ppm)

Cultivated plant N P K Ca Mg
Cucumber 230 40 315 175 42
Aubergines 175 30 235 150 28
Herbs 210 80 275 180 67
Lettuce 200 50 300 200 65
Melon 186 39 235 180 25
Peppers 175 39 235 150 28
Tomato 200 50 360 185 45


Source: Schon, M., 1992, in Proceedings of the 13th Annual Conference on Hydroponics, Hydroponic Society of America, ed. D. Shact, 1992, Hydroponic Society of America, Hrsg. San Ramon, CA.

 

So knowing the ppm content of each mineral in the solution is the most accurate way to determine the quality of the nutrient solution. However, this requires a detailed test, which is not cheap and takes some time. For this reason it should be done in a commercial production. For hobby gardeners it is not convenient and cheap.
They often measure the ppm value of the nutrient solution and observe the condition of the water and the plants to guess which nutrients the plants need. Then they add the appropriate minerals.
 
 
Conclusion

Every hydroponic grower should have an EC / PPM / TDS meter. This takes the guesswork out of the critical process of plant nutrition - at least in large part. To a beginner, EC and TDS may seem too complicated. But once you get the basics down, you'll see that it's simpler than it looks.
 
The biggest confusion comes from the different conversion factors. Unfortunately, there is not much you can do about this, as different salts have different conversion factors. If you want the most accurate measurements, e.g. for advanced or experimental cropping systems, you need to have a lab test done to get the accuracy you need. This is what we offer you here.
 
But for beginners and hobby growers, EC meters are more than enough.

Context:  

ID: 402

Subcategories

de
 
Hier finden Sie Software rund um unsere Aquaponik- und Hydroponik-Steueranlagen. Darüber hinaus Tips und HowTo's zu allen Aspekten der Steuer-, Regel- und Dokumentationssoftware.
Für einen Download unserer Software melden Sie sich bitte zuerst an (Login). Diese ist nicht öffentlich zugänglich.

en
 
Here you will find software for our aquaponics and hydroponics control systems. In addition, tips and HowTo's on all aspects of the control, regulation and documentation software.
To download our software, please register first ( Login ). This is not publicly accessible.

Jacopa Romel / Ilaria Mauric CC 2.0 / ROI = Return of Invest
 
 ID TAG: 40
feed-image RSS